A dilemma exists any time there is a need to buy new barge
unloading equipment. What equipment is available, how much does
it cost me initially and in the long run and who is going to operate
it.
Friction cranes are very popular however, most manufacturers
went out of business at the end of the 1980s due to a number of
factors such as inflation and the wide spread introduction to
hydraulic excavators. The days of the friction crane are nearly
over. It is hard to find a good machine and even harder to find
someone to run it. Throughout the 1990s, modified excavators became
available with material handling fronts which evolved into the
modern day material handlers.
These machines are readily available, are easy to operate and
are fast but they have a lot of drawbacks.
- high fuel consumption (you move the boom as well as the load)
- short life expectancy (10,000 hr rebuild, scrap at 20,000
hrs)
- short outreach (50ft is the practical limit but 70ft is possible)
- high initial cost relative to machine size
- restricted ability to stack material
- outreach is restricted when digging below base
When you look around, there are literally thousands of old style
friction cranes running to-day that were built as far back as
the late 1960s. These machines last 5 times longer than any material
handler but are difficult to operate and are expensive to maintain
and re-build.
PLM Cranes of the Netherlands has the ideal machine which has
all the advantages of an old style crane and all the advantages
of a material handler.

PLM builds hydraulic duty cycle cranes for clamshell
work such as dredging and material handling. The machines are
diesel or electric over hydraulic, power up, power down with all
ropes on one layer of the drums. Any operator familiar with heavy
equipment can become very proficient with a few days practice.
These machines are like the old friction cranes in the sense that
they last up to 100,000 hours or more but they are simple machines
with very few components and operate like an excavator.
The draw works consist of a diesel engine or electric
motor powering a pump drive with fully enclosed planetary gearing
on each drum. The systems are very simple, easy to maintain and
easy to obtain parts. PLM uses suppliers such as:
- Caterpillar engines and crawler components
- Rexroth pumps and motors
- Lohman planetary drives
- Gates hoses
- Parker valves and solenoids
These machines are built for operation on the open sea as ship's
gear and dredging cranes where the risk of losing oil into the
environment is a major concern. With an excavator or material
handler, it is only a question of time before a major incident
happens. These machines have high volume, high pressure hydraulics
all the way out the boom with direct exposure.
PLM cranes have all the hydraulics and coolants inside the machinery
house which is designed as a saveall. In the event of a component
failure, loss of pilot pressure shuts the crane down and any lost
fluid remains in the house. Purpose built drains in the bottom
of the house are used to remove the lost fluids.
When you compare bucket size and outreach, a small crane can
outperform a large material handler and last 5 times longer. Before
you buy a material handler, check out the PLMs, you will be very
pleasantly surprised. Advantages of a PLM over a material handler
are:
- low intial cost and low operating cost
- environmentally safe
- low fuel consumption (you don't lift the boom)
- easy to operate (you will not be held for ransom by the need
for high skill level)
- excellent outreach
- not restricted in outreach by depth above or below the base
of the machine
- long life, up to 5 times longer than a material handler
- lowest cost per ton of all alternatives for barge unloading
- high reliability
- high parts availability
- simple, rugged construction.
Of the more than 220 machines PLM has built since 1988, all are
in daily duty cycle service. Most owners of PLMs own more than
one machine and almost all PLMs are owned by the original purchaser.
|